The Ideal Ruler Of Kant s Ruler - 1070 Words

The Ideal Ruler How should our ideal rulers and government behave? The question has been asked for centuries and is still asked today. In 1516, Niccolà ² Machiavelli attempted to answer this question in his work The Prince(Machiavelli 8). Centuries later a different view of an ideal ruler was proposed by an Enlightenment writer, Immanuel Kant. Although Niccolà ² Machiavelli and Immanuel Kant lived 250 years apart, both views have advantages and disadvantages in leading a country, Kant s ruler is a early model of a democratic ruler while Machiavelli s ruler was an ideal model for a absolute monarch. Immanuel Kant s view of an ideal leader is more beneficial to the European society during the Enlightenment since it reflect the characteristics of a democratic ruler. The ideal ruler Kant describes is fair, protects the freedom of man, and acts on the thoughts of his people. Insight about an ideal ruler can be gained by comparing and contrasting the views of these two great thinkers. Fairness in the treatment of his people is important to a democratic government and Immanuel Kant s described ruler. Immanuel Kant says an ideal ruler should treat a man according to their dignity (158). In contrast, Machiavelli s ideal ruler only must appear to be fair and compassionate. Machiavelli stated ruler must be Prudent in escaping the evil reputation attached to those vices (9). So a ruler only need the reputation of fairness and not the actual act itself. Fairness inShow MoreRelatedAn Analysis Of Euripides The Suppliants 1372 Words   |  6 PagesPlato describes the grave consequences of placing the power into the one or the few in his ideal yet authoritarian state. There are many issues with Euripides’ quote. Firstly, the term ‘proper judgment’ is extremely abstract. For instance, Machiavelli and Kant would have very different ideas on what ‘proper judgment’ may be, but both are thought to be notable political philosophers. The decisions rulers make will always be criticized by one group of people, so it is difficult to say for certainRead MoreFrench Revolution Vs. Immanuel Kant1265 Words   |  6 PagesDWC 201, Dr. Moffett Allison Lancaster Essay #1 French Revolution vs. Immanuel Kant In 1614, France’s Population changed dramatically. The citizens were placed in three classes of rank in society. These classes consisted of the Nobels, who were born of royal blood, the Aristocrats, who were independently wealthy, and then the rest of the population who were less fortunate in life. These non-aristocratic members made up 98 percent of the Third Estate, but even so, could still be outvotedRead MorePolitics, Society And The State Of Nature930 Words   |  4 PagesThough Rousseau and Kant state that civil society and humanity amongst citizens can only be found if they are not related to the state of nature, in their explanation of laws and society in their political recommendations, the visibility of the state of nature is evident. However, their ways of clarifying nature are not the traditional way. They took a more aggressive approach to defining the purpose of state of nature in relation to politics and society. The reason why Rousseau and Kant deny the conne ctionRead MoreThe Political Of Political Science Essay2347 Words   |  10 Pagespolitical philosophy has to have public face and public dimension.(Michael sandel)(Mughan,2012) Well,In my article I am going to present Plato,Thomas Hobbes and Jean Jacques Rousseau political thinkers their politiucalphilosophy,an analysis of their ideal state theory,their thoughts in practice. Theoritical Framework Political Theory and Political Philosophy Political Philosophy begins with the question what should be a person relationship to society?Although Political Theory and Political PhilosophyRead MoreWomen s Right For Equality1467 Words   |  6 Pagesachievements, as well as their missteps. Though we are making an effort to improve women s right for equality, the American dream is still yet to be achieved by many mothers, sisters, aunts, wives, and daughters. Yes all men are created equal but are women created equal as well? Their could be some discrepancy amongst the world that will say yes but women are a minority in this country. Men are the rulers over America, being very forgetful that because of women they live a productive lifestyleRead MoreTo What Extent Was The Enlightenment The Main Driving Force Behind The American And French Revolutions?1479 Words   |  6 PagesEnlightenment thinkers whereas the purpose of this investigation was to identify the Enlightenment s impact on the start of revolutions and explore oth er possible causes. Therefore, the scope of the source failed to agree with the scope of this investigation. Furthermore, the origin of this source is valuable because the authors have received education at prestigious universities and have earned degrees and PhD s in the fields of philosophy and political theory. Although the authors effectively assess andRead MoreThe Is The Choice For The Welfare Of All1919 Words   |  8 PagesIn an ideal world, democracy would stand as the preferable choice for the welfare of all. However, in the real world, this is not always the case. Today, the term dictatorship typically yields a negative connotation. Many associate this term with a ruler acting in force and in self-interest, with the governed body suffering as a result. On the contrary, the term democracy typically yields a positive connotation and evokes positive emotion. When evaluating these terms with respect to the philosophicalRead More Plato’s Republic: Justice and Injustice in Thrasymachus Account6580 Words   |  27 Pagesindividuals who are just and obey the laws of the society; (b) the tyrant or ruler who sets down laws in the society in order to exploit the many for personal advantage; (c) the stronger individual (kreittoon) or member of the society who is detached from the many and aspires to become the tyrant. Second, I argue that if Thrasymachus’s account of the perfectly unjust life of the tyrant is to be more than a theoretical ideal, then the stronger individual who aspires to the tyrant’s position would doRead MoreAre Democracies More Than Other Kinds Of Political Regimes? Essay2269 Words   |  10 Pagesof law protects the rights of citizens, maintains order, and limits the power of government. Every person is equal under the law (Barkawi and Laffey, 2001). Further, Democracy is largely supported by liberal thinkers such as John Locke and Immanuel Kant, and liberalism is the main theory, which supports democracy and identifi es the crucial aspects of democracy. Liberalism is considered as an alternative theoretical thinking to realism, which is regarded as the dominant theory in the internationalRead MoreCauses of 2003 Us Iraq War3883 Words   |  16 Pagesin order to determine the causes for war. Kant describes three conditions that are needed for perpetual peace, the first being that the citizens of a state will begin to demand economic and judicial rights. They will demand that their government be accountable for its policies and laws. This will establish the state as a liberal state and it will begin the process of becoming a democracy. A democracy with a republican constitution is preferred by Kant because, if fortune directs that a powerful